Date of Graduation
Fall 2026
Degree
Master of Arts in Religious Studies
Department
Languages, Cultures & Religions
Committee Chair
Philippa Koch
Abstract
Cryptids, creatures like Bigfoot who are not proven yet widely believed to exist, are prevalent in American culture and are often associated closely with other monsters or supernatural beings. Scholars have investigated the cultural impact of cryptids generally, yet little attention has been given to the specific relationship between cryptids and religion. In this thesis, I will argue that cryptids have a distinct cultural position from that of other monsters and that cryptid legends and legacies can be reflective of religious trends in the United States. Using Mary Douglas and scholars of Monster Theory such as Jeffrey Jerome Cohen as a framework, I demonstrate how cryptids share similarities but are ultimately different from other monsters and creatures, such as unicorns or Frankenstein’s monster. By examining a brief history of monsters and the individual histories of Bigfoot, Mothman, and the Jersey Devil, I also demonstrate the parallel aspects between the belief in or reception of these cryptids and religious sentiments like New Age Spiritualism, rural religion, and secularism. American religion incorporates a great deal of diversity, and this is true also in the legends of the three chosen cryptids. This thesis finds that cryptids are not monsters or religious beings but liminal animals that are interwoven into the cultural and religious landscape of the United States by virtue of their unique ontological status and complex history.
Keywords
cryptids, religion in America, monster theory, Conservative Christianity, secularism, Bigfoot, Mothman, Jersey Devil, New Age Spiritualism, rural religion
Subject Categories
American Popular Culture | Christian Denominations and Sects | Cultural History | Folklore | Other Religion
Copyright
© Ashley G. Jones
Recommended Citation
Jones, Ashley G., "Mothman and Jesus: How Cryptids Reflect Religion in America" (2026). Graduate Theses/Dissertations. 4212.
https://bearworks.missouristate.edu/theses/4212
Open Access
Included in
American Popular Culture Commons, Christian Denominations and Sects Commons, Cultural History Commons, Folklore Commons, Other Religion Commons